‘THE GREAT DEGENERATION’

THE GREAT DEGENERATION: HOW INSTITUTIONS DECAY AND ECONOMIES DIE
By Niall Ferguson
Penguin Press, $26.95, 153 pages

Washington Times on July 18, 2013, published a review by Ray V. Hartwell III of professor Niall Ferguson’s new book The Great Degeneration. One of Ferguson’s earlier books, “The Ascent of Money,” became the basis for an award-winning PBS series. Mr. Ferguson is also a professor at Harvard and a senior research fellow at Oxford’s Jesus College and Stanford University’s Hoover Institution. Excerpts below:

In “The Great Degeneration,” Mr. Ferguson has produced a succinct and insightful book about the major political and economic issues confronting USA today. He provides not only a perceptive analysis of…past successes, but also a sobering diagnosis of our present and future. He skillfully musters support from the likes of Adam Smith, Edmund Burke, Alexis de Tocqueville and Charles Dickens, in addition to a host of more contemporary figures. Although his principal focus is the United States, on which as a Scot he offers observations unhindered by political partisanship, his assessments can be applied to all Western democracies.

Mr. Ferguson explains lucidly that even as we are distracted by “the slanging match that passes for political debate in the United States today,” our country has entered a new era of decline. We have become what Adam Smith called a “stationary state”: a “formerly wealthy country” that has “ceased to grow,” and displays the hallmarks of relatively low and stagnant wages for the masses, coupled with “the ability of a corrupt and monopolistic elite to exploit the system of law and administration for their own advantage.”

The author’s theme is that past successes — and current predicament — have not been driven by climate, resources, culture or religion, but rather by “laws and institutions.” In assessing “what exactly has gone wrong in the Western world in our time,” Mr. Ferguson focuses on four “key components of our civilization” — democracy or representative government, capitalism or free markets, the rule of law, and “civil society.” Within these “political, economic, legal and social black boxes are highly complex sets of interlocking institutions,” which he undertakes to examine in search of defects or degeneration.

Mr. Ferguson recognizes the virtues of representative government, but details with dismay the huge debts amassed by the Western democracies in recent decades.

Considering capitalism, Mr. Ferguson turns to the recent financial crisis for his teaching example. He places blame for the crisis not on “deregulation,” but on “over-complex regulation” that “inadvertently helped to inflate a real estate bubble.

After a shock that could have caused “mass extinctions,” moreover, “dinosaurs still roam the financial world.” To make a complex financial environment “less fragile” requires “simplicity of regulation and strength of enforcement.”

Turning to the law, the author catalogs “the ways in which the rule of law, broadly defined, has degenerated in Western societies.” The rule of law has “many enemies,” Mr. Ferguson notes, and he counts “among its most dangerous foes the authors of very long and convoluted laws.”…the United States is “manifestly slipping behind” a number of economic rivals. This is “a remarkable phenomenon in itself,” and the author finds it “even more remarkable that it is happening almost unnoticed by Americans.” Once we had the rule of law, and now “what we see is the rule of lawyers.”

Mr. Ferguson also notes the decline in citizen engagement, as reflected in lower participation in private associations of all types. This [depends on] the state’s promise of cradle-to-grave security, which the author sees as “the real enemy of civil society.” We need “more private initiative and less dependence on the state,” a view once “considered the essence of true liberalism.”

In conclusion, Mr. Ferguson observes that countries reach Adam Smith’s “stationary state” when their laws and institutions “degenerate to the point that elite rent-seeking dominates the economic and political process.” Regulation has become “dysfunctional,” lawyers evolve from “revolutionaries” into “parasites,” and civil society “withers into a mere no man’s land between corporate interests and big government.” This is the “Great Degeneration.”
This is a powerful and persuasive book. I heartily recommend it.

Ray V. Hartwell III, a Washington lawyer, is a senior fellow of the Alabama Policy Institute.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: